Hello from Israel-Palestine.
In the spring of 2023, I had the opportunity to live in Hebron for about a month, where I jumpstarted my spoken Arabic and made friendships that I anticipate will last a lifetime.
I was self-conscious approaching my trip because of the history of Jewish people coming to Hebron after 1967, not leaving, and displacing Palestinian people violently. So, my foremost intention was to be a good guest.
About halfway through my time here, I realized that I was living about a fifteen-minute walk from Be’er Haram Ar-Rameh. This archaeological site is venerated as the location of Abraham & Sarah’s tent whose biblical name “Mamre” in Genesis 18 persists on street signs in English and Arabic to this day. I had already felt privileged to be so warmly welcomed at every step of my experience—perhaps a romanticized experience of living in the city that is often regarded as a distillation of the Occupation because of the heavy militarized presence of a small number of Jews who have been abetted by Israel in making their homes here.
Little did I realize that the origin story of our mitzvah of hachnasat orchim, welcoming guests, was a three-minute taxi ride from my doorstep—the place where Abraham sat recovering from his circumcision, the place where both Sarah and Abraham laughed when three visitors announced there would be a second child—in their old age. Three years later, and several trips back, I kept feeling drawn to the site and wanted to share it with you in these weeks as Tisha B’av approaches.
The Talmud famously relates the story of Kamtza and Bar Kamtza (B.T. Gittin, 55b) the latter of whom was mistakenly invited to a party in place of his friend-with-a-similar-name. In a display of sinat chinam, baseless hatred, rather than quietly resolving the matter, even after Bar Kamtza offered to pay for the party, the host publicly embarrassed Bar Kamtza, an incident that our sages link to the destruction of the Second Temple.
The reason I came to Hebron to learn Arabic three years ago was because I wanted to be able to carefully listen to people’s stories and share those stories—after all, my spoken Hebrew had been proficient for a long time. And as an American Jew, I have been able to enjoy a unique freedom of movement in the land of which I thought I could take advantage to contribute some small degree to the people in the land where Israel has created so many barriers and walls. My time here sometimes inspires me to frame the Occupation through the lens of egregious violations of hospitality person by person by person rather than through the lens of political power on the international stage. It has helped me understand why, both ancient Greek and Jewish traditions have imagined the Procrustean Bed/Bed of Sodom along the way to a society’s ultimate corruption.
But just as there can be baseless hatred, there can be baseless love, love for its own sake. And just as a society can become corrupt when people neglect to be good guests or good hosts, transformative experiences are possible when people offer hospitality without condition. Witness the powerful stories of welcoming thousands of “strangers” into communities in Newfoundland on September 11, 2001, as recounted in Come From Away.
From whistles on key chains to petitioning for policy change, from creating alliances to watching at courtroom doors, the End Deportation movement to which so JFREJers have dedicated our time and resources is at its heart an amplification of the mitzvah of hachnasat orchim that originated right here in Hebron over my shoulders. Our progenitors in Sarah and Abraham taught us from this tent to eschew xenophobia, to eschew a mentality of scarcity.
There is enough for everyone. There is enough land. There is enough to eat. There is enough possibility. I know that the echoes of that hospitality that have never left this besieged city thousands of years later and that this call to hospitality also echoes across sea and ocean as we dream and act to deliver on our highest aspirations for America. May you always have the experience to feel welcome, just as you have shown people that they are welcome.
- Rabbi Jason Klein